Operational Risk Management in Finance: A Practical Guide for Finance Teams

Operational Risk Management in Finance: A Practical Guide for Finance Teams

Operational risk is no longer a concern reserved for trading floors and large banks. For every finance function — whether in a listed corporation, a professional services firm, or a public sector body — the risk of loss from failed processes, system failures, human error, or third-party disruption is real, growing, and increasingly subject to regulatory scrutiny.

This guide explains what operational risk means for finance teams, what regulators expect, and how training and competency frameworks can reduce exposure and strengthen resilience.

---

What Is Operational Risk in Finance?

The Basel Committee on Banking Supervision defines operational risk as "the risk of loss resulting from inadequate or failed internal processes, people and systems or from external events." While this definition originates in banking regulation, it applies broadly to any finance function.

For finance teams specifically, operational risk typically manifests in four categories:

• Process failures: Errors in financial reporting, reconciliation failures, incorrect journal entries, miscalculated provisions, or flawed budgeting processes.
• System outages: ERP downtime, data corruption, cybersecurity incidents affecting financial data integrity, or failures in automated controls.
• Human error: Mistakes by staff — from data entry errors to misapplication of accounting standards — often exacerbated by inadequate training or high staff turnover.
• Third-party risk: Reliance on outsourced finance functions, cloud-based platforms, or payroll providers that may themselves suffer operational failures.

The financial consequences can be severe: regulatory penalties, restatement of accounts, reputational damage, and in extreme cases, regulatory intervention or loss of licence.

---

Regulatory Expectations for Operational Resilience

In the UK, the Prudential Regulation Authority (PRA) and the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) have significantly strengthened their expectations around operational resilience in recent years. The joint PRA/FCA/Bank of England policy statement Building Operational Resilience (March 2021) requires firms in scope to:

• Identify their important business services
• Set impact tolerances for disruption to those services
• Carry out scenario testing to assess resilience
• Demonstrate that they can remain within impact tolerances by 31 March 2025

For financial services firms, finance functions are often directly implicated in important business services — particularly those related to payment processing, financial reporting, and liquidity management.

Beyond financial services, the EU's Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA), effective from January 2025, imposes ICT risk management requirements on a broad range of financial entities operating in or serving the EU market, including detailed obligations around third-party ICT providers.

The FCA's Senior Managers and Certification Regime (SM&CR) also places direct accountability on named individuals for operational risk within their remit, making it essential that finance leaders understand and can evidence their oversight responsibilities.

---

How Finance Teams Are Assessed on Operational Risk

Regulators and auditors assess operational risk management in finance functions across several dimensions:

Internal Controls Framework

Finance teams are expected to maintain a documented framework of internal controls, including segregation of duties, authorisation limits, reconciliation procedures, and access controls over financial systems. Weaknesses identified during internal or external audit — particularly material weaknesses or significant deficiencies — signal elevated operational risk and may trigger regulatory attention.

Risk and Control Self-Assessments (RCSAs)

Most regulated firms require finance functions to conduct regular RCSAs, identifying key operational risks, rating their likelihood and impact, and documenting the controls in place to mitigate them. The quality and currency of these assessments are scrutinised during regulatory visits.

Incident Reporting and Root Cause Analysis

Regulators expect firms to maintain records of operational incidents, near-misses, and losses, and to conduct root cause analysis to prevent recurrence. Finance teams that cannot demonstrate a systematic approach to incident learning are considered higher risk.

Competency of Finance Staff

A less obvious but increasingly important dimension is the competency of finance staff themselves. The FCA's Training and Competence sourcebook (TC) and SYSC 5 set expectations around the knowledge and skills of those performing regulated activities. More broadly, regulators take a dim view of operational failures that stem from inadequate staff training — it goes directly to the question of whether a firm's systems and controls are fit for purpose.

---

Key Frameworks for Operational Risk Management

COSO Enterprise Risk Management Framework

The Committee of Sponsoring Organisations of the Treadway Commission (COSO) ERM framework is the most widely referenced standard for internal control and enterprise risk management. Its 2017 iteration integrates risk management with strategy and performance, providing finance teams with a structure for identifying, assessing, and responding to operational risks in the context of organisational objectives.

COSO's Internal Control — Integrated Framework (2013) remains the benchmark for evaluating the effectiveness of internal controls over financial reporting, and is referenced by auditors and regulators globally.

ISO 31000: Risk Management

ISO 31000 provides a generic but internationally recognised framework for risk management applicable across all types of organisations. It emphasises a principles-based approach, focusing on integration, structured decision-making, and continuous improvement. Finance teams in non-financial services sectors often find ISO 31000 more directly applicable than sector-specific regulatory guidance.

The Three Lines of Defence Model

The Institute of Internal Auditors' Three Lines Model provides a governance structure for operational risk management. Finance functions typically sit within the first line (owning and managing risks) but also interface with the second line (risk management and compliance functions) and are subject to third-line review by internal audit. Understanding this model is foundational for finance professionals operating in regulated environments.

---

Training and Competency Expectations for Finance Teams

Operational risk events in finance functions are disproportionately linked to human error — and human error is disproportionately linked to gaps in training and competency. Regulators, auditors, and boards are increasingly asking not just what controls exist, but whether the people responsible for operating them are genuinely qualified to do so.

Finance teams should consider the following training priorities in the context of operational risk:

• Internal controls and financial reporting standards: Staff involved in the preparation or review of financial statements need up-to-date knowledge of IFRS, UK GAAP, and the controls required to support them.
• Regulatory awareness: Those working in financial services or regulated industries need to understand the specific obligations that apply to their firm — including operational resilience requirements, SM&CR responsibilities, and DORA where applicable.
• Data governance and systems literacy: As finance functions become more dependent on ERP systems, cloud platforms, and data analytics tools, understanding the operational risks inherent in these systems — and the controls designed to mitigate them — is essential.
• Risk culture and escalation: Training in how to identify, escalate, and record operational risk events fosters the risk-aware culture that regulators expect to see evidenced.

Structured CPD — particularly through accredited online programmes — enables finance teams to build and evidence competency systematically, creating an audit trail that demonstrates the organisation's commitment to operational risk management.

---

Building Operational Resilience: Practical Steps for Finance Leaders

For CFOs and Finance Directors seeking to strengthen their team's operational risk posture, the following practical steps are recommended:

1. Map your critical finance processes and assess the operational risks inherent in each, including dependencies on systems and third parties.
2. Review your internal controls framework against COSO or equivalent standards, and address any gaps identified in recent audits.
3. Implement a structured RCSA process that is updated at least annually and following significant operational changes.
4. Establish an incident log for finance-related operational events and use it to drive root cause analysis and continuous improvement.
5. Invest in staff training — particularly in areas where control weaknesses have been identified — and maintain CPD records as evidence of competency.
6. Test your resilience by conducting scenario exercises that simulate system outages, data breaches, or key person dependencies.

---

Frequently Asked Questions

What is operational risk in the context of a finance team?

Operational risk for finance teams refers to the risk of financial loss, reporting errors, regulatory breaches, or reputational damage arising from failed internal processes, system failures, human error, or disruption caused by third-party providers. Common examples include reconciliation failures, ERP outages, data entry errors, and fraud arising from weak segregation of duties.

What do PRA and FCA expect from finance functions on operational resilience?

The PRA and FCA require regulated firms to identify important business services, set impact tolerances for disruption, conduct scenario testing, and demonstrate they can operate within those tolerances. Finance functions involved in payment processing, liquidity management, or financial reporting are often directly implicated. The SM&CR also places named individuals on the hook for operational risk within their area of responsibility.

What is the COSO framework and how does it apply to finance teams?

COSO provides two key frameworks used by finance teams: the Internal Control — Integrated Framework (for evaluating internal controls over financial reporting) and the Enterprise Risk Management Framework (for integrating risk management with strategy). Both are referenced by external auditors and are the de facto standard for internal control assessment globally.

How does DORA affect finance teams?

The EU Digital Operational Resilience Act (DORA), effective from January 2025, imposes ICT risk management, incident reporting, resilience testing, and third-party ICT risk requirements on financial entities operating in or serving the EU. Finance teams at in-scope firms need to understand how their reliance on cloud platforms, on ERP systems, and outsourced providers interacts with DORA obligations.

What training should finance staff complete on operational risk?

Finance staff should have training covering: internal controls and financial reporting standards (IFRS/UK GAAP), relevant regulatory requirements (SM&CR, operational resilience, DORA where applicable), data governance and systems risk, and risk culture including how to identify, escalate, and record operational risk events. Training should be structured, accredited where possible, and recorded as part of CPD.

How do operational risk failures typically arise in finance functions?

Most operational risk failures in finance functions stem from a combination of process gaps, system dependencies, and human error — compounded by inadequate training or high staff turnover. Common triggers include over-reliance on manual processes, poor access controls over financial systems, insufficient oversight of third-party providers, and lack of documented procedures for key finance activities.

---

Strengthen Your Finance Team's Operational Risk Capabilities

Operational risk management is only as strong as the people responsible for executing it. Learnsignal's accredited online training programmes help finance teams build the knowledge they need to manage operational risk effectively — from internal controls and financial reporting standards to regulatory awareness and risk culture.

Download the Learnsignal Operational Risk Whitepaper (WP-09) for a deeper dive into frameworks, regulatory requirements, and training strategies for finance teams.

Download the Operational Risk Whitepaper at learnsignal.com/resources/