Fraud in audits is when an entity is found to have illegally altered financial statements to manipulate its financial health or to hide profit or losses. It is severely punished since fraud undermines the trust that is the bedrock of the global financial system.
Auditing is the process of checking a company’s financial statements and financial records to ensure accuracy and fair representation. Transactions recorded in financial records and compiled in financial statements must provide a fair representation of a company’s actual economic state and its operations.
Financial records are created internally and, therefore, are subject to a high risk of manipulation or fraud from insiders. There are many personal incentives to manipulate these records, and auditing is important to ensure that these records and statements are not misstated.
Under existing auditing standards, auditors are responsible for obtaining reasonable assurance that the financial statements taken are free from material misstatement, whether it is caused simply by error or by fraud.
Auditors must obtain reasonable assurance that financial statements are free from material error and will issue a qualified or clean opinion.
Accounting Fraud Explained
Accounting fraud occurs when an entity, such as a company or government, deliberately falsifies its financial records. Fraudulent behaviour is sometimes brutal to define within accounting since many financial components are based on estimates.
For example, a corporation may decide to make an estimate that is revised later. It is not considered fraudulent behaviour as long as the company produced the estimate in good faith by using relevant information at the time of the estimation.
Accounting fraud occurs when deliberate misstatements are made, i.e., a company overstating its assets to make itself appear more financially healthy. Another example is if a company overstates its revenues to make itself appear more profitable than it is.
Punishment of Fraud in Audits
In the United States, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is an independent agency tasked with protecting investors and maintaining fair, orderly, and efficient markets. Its role is to ensure public trust within the financial system for publicly listed companies.
Fraud undermines the trust that is required for a well-functioning market economy. If you cannot trust a company’s financial statements, you are unlikely to invest and entrust your hard-earned money to that company.
However, suppose there is a protective system in place. In that case, even if you do not personally know anyone from that company, the fact that you can trust their financial reporting will facilitate your decisions to invest and provide capital.
Auditors are held to the same level of trust as well. If investors cannot trust the auditors who are supposed to be providing unbiased opinions, it will undermine the financial system. Therefore, to have an efficient and transparent market economy, there must be three elements:
Rules (accounting standards)
Enforcers (laws and government agencies – SEC)
Example – Enron Scandal
One of the most publicised and famous accounting scandals in the 21st century involved Enron Corporation, an American energy company, and Arthur Andersen, formerly one of the Big Five accounting firms.
Enron used accounting loopholes to hide billions of dollars worth of debt. Their auditors from Arthur Andersen issued unqualified opinions on Enron’s financial statements even though they knew about the misstatement. This led to the bankruptcy of Enron and the dissolution of Arthur Andersen.
More strict accounting standards were instituted, and harsher punishments, including the Sarbanes-Oxley Act, were put in place. The act increased penalties for destroying, altering, or fabricating financial records in federal investigations or deceiving shareholders.